Paul Cornish
Wednesday 13 June 2018
'The Somme set the picture by which future generations saw the First World War; brave helpless soldiers; blundering obstinate generals; nothing achieved'.

So wrote the historian A J P Taylor in his 1963 book The First World War: An Illustrated History. Despite – or more probably because of – its mixture of irreverence and boldly voiced opinion, this book can still lay claim to being the most read English language history of the war. Its success has undoubtedly contributed to the fact that this sentence rings as true for many today as it did half a century ago.

art

Wartime perceptions

art

Wartime perceptions

The Battle of the Somme as seen by Britain's first official war artist, Muirhead Bone. Exhibitions and published volumes of his drawings proved hugely popular.

The Battle of the Somme as seen by Britain's first official war artist, Muirhead Bone. Exhibitions and published volumes of his drawings proved hugely popular.
The Battle of the Somme as seen by Britain's first official war artist, Muirhead Bone. Exhibitions and published volumes of his drawings proved hugely popular.

But this was far from the view of the battle during the First World War. The Battle of the Somme saw the first major action of Britain's New Army – the volunteers who had responded to Lord Kitchener's 1914 call for recruits. It was also the first Western Front offensive in which the British Army would take the leading role, rather than acting in support of its French ally. 

The government and War Office ensured that the battle was covered not only by carefully selected journalists, but by literary figures such as John Masefield and John Buchan. Official photographers were despatched to the front for the first time and the British public were soon able to see and purchase drawings of the battle by Britain's first official war artist, Muirhead Bone. Above all though, they flocked to see the film The Battle of the Somme and its follow-up The Battle of the Ancre and the Advance of the Tanks. An estimated 20 million Britons watched the former following its release in August 1916, with the battle only recently commenced.

photographs

Wiltshire Regiment attack at Thiepval, 7 August 1916

photographs

Wiltshire Regiment attack at Thiepval, 7 August 1916

Sometimes the Battle of the Somme really did match our modern-day image of it. Here men of the Wiltshire Regiment attack at Thiepval on 7 August 1916.

 

 

Men of the Wiltshire Regiment advancing to the attack through the wire, Thiepval, 7 August 1916.
Sometimes the Battle of the Somme really did match our modern-day image of it. Here men of the Wiltshire Regiment attack at Thiepval on 7 August 1916.

In all these representations the battle was depicted as an arduous but worthwhile endeavour, undertaken by cheerful but determined men. Perhaps surprisingly, given the terrible casualties sustained in the battle, this vision was shared by many soldiers. Despite the ghastliness of the battle, they believed that, for the first time, they had gained the upper hand on the Western Front. An American visitor to the front reported that 'the general feeling seems to be one of disappointment that more was not accomplished, but also of satisfaction that marked superiority had been shown to the Germans in much of the fighting'.

photographs

Disenchantment

photographs

Disenchantment

A British photograph of dead German soldiers in a trench. The heavy German casualties on the Somme seldom feature in British visions of the battle.

Only after the war did less enthusiastic views of the battle begin to circulate. The most influential came from the pens of two wartime politicians: Winston Churchill in The World Crisis Vol III (1927) and David Lloyd George in War Memoirs Vol II (1933). Both had personal reasons for denouncing the conduct of the battle, as both had been advocates of a strategy focused away from the costly Western Front. 

Another interwar advocate of an 'indirect' strategy of this sort was the military writer, Basil Liddell Hart – himself invalided out of the Army after being gassed on the Somme. He acted as military advisor to Lloyd George for his memoirs and promoted his own views in books and as a military correspondent for newspapers. For Liddell Hart the Somme represented all that was wrong with Britain's conduct of the First World War.

photographs

French infantrymen on the march

photographs

French infantrymen on the march

French infantrymen on the march during the Battle of the Somme. The French Army's role in the Battle of the Somme has been largely forgotten in Britain today.

The publication of these views coincided with a broader expression of 'disenchantment' with the war, in novels, poems and memoirs. All of this chimed with the mood of the times, with the British people determined to avoid another 'Great War'. When war did come, fears of another costly Western Front, of another Somme, pervaded British military thinking. 

From the late 1950s there was a resurgence of interest in the First World War, with several new books of popular history taking up the 'disenchantment' theme once more. It was this renewed interest which spawned A J P Taylor’s book and, finally, the BBC documentary series The Great War. This series achieved huge viewing figures. Interestingly, its take on the Somme was far from condemnatory – a fact that prompted the very public resignation of Sir Basil Liddell Hart as historical advisor to the series.

photographs

'One sacred day'

photographs

'One sacred day'

This still is from one of the most famous scenes in the documentary film The Battle of the Somme. It has been estimated that 20 million people watched the film when it was released in 1916.

From 1967 the official papers for the period of the battle became available to historians, but this did little to reconcile the opposing views of its conduct. An unfortunate side effect was that the battle became viewed narrowly as a British affair. Only recently have historians begun to take a broader approach, examining the important part played by the French Army and the experience of the Germans who fought there. But this work has had little influence on public perceptions of the battle.

A further development in recent years has seen the Battle of the Somme come to dominate British understanding of the First World War as a whole. Battles and campaigns such as Passchendaele or Gallipoli, the names of which were once equally resonant, have faded into relative obscurity. What is more, our focus has narrowed still further by being concentrated largely on the disasters of 1 July 1916. Historian David Reynolds has recently suggested that the whole 'meaning of Britain's Great War' had been 'whittled down' to this 'one sacred day'.

The Battle of the Somme continues to inspire authors and historians, but the availability of books that offer complete and nuanced studies of this titanic five-month battle has had only a limited impact on popular perceptions of it. In most people's imagination the Somme is the overriding emblem of the Western Front and indeed of the war in its entirety. However, it can hardly be considered surprising that the most costly battle in Britain's most costly war should feature so strongly in our shared memory.

Related Content

A view of a large, sunlit crater blasted into white chalky soil. The remains of German barbed-wire defences in the distance are a dark rust-coloured pink. A German and a British steel helmet and the remains of a uniform lie on the edge of the crater in the foreground. The sky is covered in dense white cloud with blue patches visible at the top of the composition.
First World War
5 Things You Need To Know About The Battle Of The Somme
The Battle of the Somme was one of the most bitterly contested and costly battles of the First World War, lasting nearly five months. Despite this, it is often the first day of the battle that is most remembered. 
The 20th Deccan Horse, Indian Army, in Carnoy Valley, 7th Divisional Area, 14th July 1916.
© IWM (Q 825)
Battle of the Somme
The Role Of Empire And Commonwealth Troops During The Battle Of The Somme
Soldiers from the Empire and Commonwealth made a significant contribution to the Somme offensive. On 1 July 1916 a battalion from Newfoundland, attacked with the 29th Division, while the 1st Battalion, The Lincolnshire Regiment included a contingent from the Bermuda Volunteer Rifle Corps.
Trench mortar ammunition behind the lines. Acheux, 28th June 1916.
First World War
Voices of the First World War: The First Day Of The Somme
Episode 23: The Battle of the Somme is one of the most famous military events in British history – synonymous with huge loss of life and costly failure. After months of deadlock on the Western Front, a joint British and French offensive was planned to break through the German lines north of the River Somme in mid-1916.